5 Comments
Apr 2Liked by Cartoons Hate Her

A favorite New Yorker cartoon. Group of students on campus:”My writing workshop professor says to write what I know but what I know is writing workshops.”

Expand full comment
Apr 2Liked by Cartoons Hate Her

Maybe the choice is because think their readers see a writer them as creative, imaginative, exciting people, yet tortured by inner demons, trying to express the joy, the sadness, the beauty and horrorof the world. Like a pre-rolled character that only needs to be tweaked any further. Kind of cheating, though.

I try to avoid it in my stories. And I know any time I admitted in a pub to being a writer, it might have got me a very brief status bump, but that devolved quickly into endless questions on what did I write, and that's not what they like, and why don't I write a story about [insert random idea]?

Expand full comment

This goes for movies too! No more "movies about the movies."*

*unless your movie stars the Muppets, in which case please do make it about show business

Expand full comment
Apr 2Liked by Cartoons Hate Her

I also have a "never write about writers" rule. I do love some novels about writers (e.g. Apartment by Teddy Wayne), but it's a good personal check against self-indulgence and myopia in my own (fiction) writing.

Expand full comment
author

Yes! It's one thing if the story literally depends on someone being a writer- another example of that is The Shining- but otherwise, get creative!

Expand full comment