But White Women--
I wrote about why middle-aged white women made liberalism uncool. People had COMMENTS.
The other day, I wrote Liberalism was Cool. Then Your Mom Became One, about how being a liberal has gone from rebellious young man coded to middle-aged lady coded, thus making it deeply uncool (for now.) It went a bit viral, which I actually didn’t expect. I almost didn’t write it, not because it felt controversial, but because this isn’t a political Substack and every time I’ve written about politics, I’ve lost more subscribers than I’ve gained (I spent countless hours on my article about RFK Jr. and the right co-opting the idea of “chemicals in food,” only to lose 11 paid subscribers for it.) Maybe this is my sign that I should write about politics more often, as long as I stay in my lane of drawing on social dynamics, nostalgia, and coolness or lack thereof.
Of course, my article about middle-aged white ladies ruining liberalism for the edgelords wasn’t in defense of us. I wasn’t asking anyone to feel bad for us, defend us, or take sides. I wasn’t even asking anyone to reassure me that my demographic is cool—we are not! One thing about my writing is I don’t really moralize or scold (#notlikeotherwhiteliberalmoms) I just notice trends. And the trend I noticed was that the “cool” edgy liberalism of my youth, popularized by Green Day, Michael Moore, and the button I had on my backpack that read “Bush Lied, People Died,” was now the territory of the resist lib MSNBC pussy hat contingent. A young person being a liberal to shock their parents is not a “thing” anymore, the same way it was unheard of in 2004 for a young person to be a dogmatic Catholic Republican in an effort to be cool and edgy.
Of course, like any viral article (especially any article with a paywall) I was bound to get pushback. I expect it, and to some extent I enjoy it, because it keeps the dialogue going. Of course, some of the pushback was very stupid. This article is about that pushback, from both sides of the aisle.
Keep reading with a 7-day free trial
Subscribe to Cartoons Hate Her to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.