Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Avocado Toast's avatar

I knew the whole oldest daughter syndrome thing had gone way too far when someone I know started trying to diagnose my daughter with it. She’s two and doesn’t even have any siblings yet.

Expand full comment
Pam B's avatar

I read too many newsletters to remember who wrote what, but someone was calling herself the eldest daughter, even though she had an older brother... because she was the first girl child. Like, that's not what 'eldest daughter' means. You weren't parentified, which is a real thing, and much of what I take eldest daughter discourse to be about: putting yourself aside for other family members, either because you were told to, or because you felt it was the right thing to do.

I'm an eldest daughter who was a rule follower and studied hard and tried to always to do the right thing. I may have regrets/a teeny bit of anger over various childhood issues, but I'm an adult and know that I wasn't truly harmed. I wasn't forced to care for my younger brother, and any high standards I felt I needed to hit were mostly self imposed and because it didn't occur to me to be otherwise.

Taylor Swift has a younger brother, but since she has been a professional musician/singer/celebrity since she was a young teen, I'm not sure how she is an eldest daughter as we define it. Rule follower and hard worker, sure. But parentified? They moved states to give her a career, uprooting her brother from his own life. If anything, it's Taylor's brother who probably has the more interesting story to tell.

Expand full comment
89 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?